The Almighty Church of Social Inclusion

18 Mar

Over the last ten years I have taken part in about 50 major European Commission conferences on Roma issues. Many were in the early years. I thought initially that conferencing was a way to achieve change. Last year I went to just one EC conference.  After the meeting I wrote a piece about structural racism that was published by the European Voice[1]. The “Extraordinary Meeting on Roma” was extraordinary proof of structural problems and ingrained racism within the Commission. Only two speakers out of 29 were Roma.

I was invited this year to another EC conference. It will be my last.

This meeting in Brussels on the 15th of March had 25 speakers. Again, two of them were Roma. Two EC directors (senior management) appeared, read what somebody else had written for them, and left. They didn’t listen to anybody else’s presentation, and they did not take questions.  Each of the middle management bureaucrats from the Commission did the same. They showed up for their panel and then promptly left.

But what can you expect when that’s what their boss does?  I have never seen Vice-President Reading – the highest-level Commission member in charge of Roma issues – take the time to listen to anything Roma practitioners had to say or to ask questions of them.  She reads the speeches someone else wrote and leaves.

Most of those in charge of Roma issues have weak or nonexistent hands-on or academic experience  (Even the best people in the Commission cannot claim more than touristic exposure to Roma communities.) Virtually their only opportunity to engage with Roma experts and practitioners is at these conferences.

But they don’t engage.  The high level bureaucrats come – deliver the sermon; we pray, take our communion (there is always free lunch and coffee), and discuss among ourselves.  Meanwhile those on high attend to more important business.

This Friday I did not want to play this game anymore.

The meeting was filled, as usual, with a good number of Roma with wide-ranging expertise as well as (non-Roma) Roma experts. Together, the directors and midlevel managers from the Commission – who came to tell us what we should do – had far fewer hours spent on Roma issues than any single one of us.

And for the first time it hit me that in fact we should behave like these senior managers. And in fact, I am busy with more important things too. I have 30 children from the ghetto who look forward to seeing me at basketball practice tomorrow.  I have Alberto, Totonel and Andrea hoping I’ll take them home for the weekend and make pancakes and fruit salad. If I stay to listen to the sermons I will lose that chance.  So I talked and walked out. A few others did the same.

Civil society should walk out. The way most EC senior managers deal with Roma issues is not only irresponsible, it is disrespectful and deeply racist. And we should call them on it.

First and foremost, the Commission needs to publish and adhere to a basic minimal standard of cooperation developed with, rather than dictated to, the Roma civil society.

The European Parliament should initiate an independent investigation of the way the European Commission uses public money on Roma. It might help transparency and accountability – things the Commission requires from everybody but itself.

The European Commission is not the almighty Church of Social Inclusion. Its imperious behaviour is an embarrassment for Europe and a major impediment to social progress.  Walk out and demand change!

Advertisements

9 Responses to “The Almighty Church of Social Inclusion”

  1. Leslie Hawke March 18, 2013 at 8:14 am #

    So true! It seems that, when in doubt, the Almighty Funders fund “meetings”. Nothing will change until — when in doubt — they, themselves, get out into the field, and discover for themselves the reality of life for the average Roma family. Not through for a 45 minute scripted photo op, (although that would be a significant start for many) but for real in-depth conversations with the actual people they call the “target group” (not just the NGO directors) and first-hand observation of how the community actually functions. I once tried to get an EC official to go with me inside one of the tenements in Rahova and she refused, saying, “I’ve seen it before” as if I were offering her a re-run of a bad movie.

    • valeriucnicolae March 18, 2013 at 12:31 pm #

      Had the same experience a number of times. You keep trying and will do the same. And thanks for everything. V

    • Peter March 18, 2013 at 3:06 pm #

      I agree and did went to many Roma families in Europe.
      Have a look at my website,
      http://Www.petervanbeek.com
      And lets talk!
      Peter

  2. Leslie Hawke March 18, 2013 at 8:16 am #

    Love the title you gave it.

  3. Peter March 18, 2013 at 3:04 pm #

    I photographed Roma for the last 10 years, ending the Decade of Roma Inclusion with a photobook! And aongoing exhibit/storytelling serie through European countries.
    I would like to cooperate and meet you, if you are interested.
    If so, i can tell you more of course
    Peter van Beek
    Netherlands

  4. Alek March 18, 2013 at 5:50 pm #

    Sad but true !

  5. Zini Kore March 18, 2013 at 6:44 pm #

    Thank you for putting it in the paper, it is my 13th year of the same burocratic attitude towards children in the street situation :((((

    Thank you again and good luck

  6. Anca March 21, 2013 at 11:28 am #

    Hi. Thank you so much for this article, I think it sums of so well this bureaucratic blockage at EC level and beyond, on the Roma issue and not only. My question as a non-expert – is there a possibility to balance between this well-justified will to walk out and the fact that supposedly these are the people with the funds (are they btw – is the money that they provide useful, and/ or is the EC actually one of the biggest funders?). What are the alternatives to walking out on these conferences – how can activists then actually make their voice heard, and make these people put the right money (and regulation) into the right type of action?

  7. Els de Groen October 17, 2014 at 11:08 am #

    True, but… those who walk out, must join to make their voice sound louder! That is also true!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: